O. Yousaf and F. Gobet of Brunel University published three experiments in The Journal of Social Psychology in 2013, with 206 participants in total (the page we read gives no per-experiment numbers). Participants were made to feel hypocritical about advocating religious behaviors they had not recently kept up to their own satisfaction. In the first experiment this produced higher self-reported guilt and shame than the control condition. In the second, a religious self-affirmation task removed the guilt and shame. In the third, participants strengthened their religious attitudes after the dissonance, and both religious and non-religious self-affirmation removed that effect. We read the abstract on a university portal, not the full paper, and the page lists no limits.
In April 2018, PsyPost reported a study in the same journal by Brien Ashdown, Jana Hackathorn and Jordan Daniels. It studied 187 self-identified Christians in the United States after the 2015 Ashley Madison data leak. Participants with higher sex guilt were more likely to demonize the site's users, its owners and the hackers. Religiosity predicted more demonization only indirectly, through its link to higher sex guilt. The article reports no effect sizes and does not describe the measures, so we are relying on a secondary summary. Ashdown noted that strong social norms against infidelity may explain why the site's users were singled out, and suggested a follow-up on behaviors that are less stigmatized.
Read together, one shows guilt and shame arising when a person's own conduct falls short of what they said they valued, and the other links higher sex guilt to harsher judgment of others. Neither can measure when the standard was first taught, who taught it, or whether the person ever agreed to it.
◆ My Take
The court has a public gallery
In the 2013 experiments, an internal gap between what people advocated and what they did was enough to produce guilt and shame, and a self-affirmation task removed it. In the 2018 study, guilt about sex went along with harsher views of people who were not in the room. The samples and designs differ, so the two do not show that one causes the other in any one person.
What neither can show is the standard itself. A person may hold a verdict against themselves and a verdict against others from the same unread agreement, and the studies only catch the verdicts. They do not catch the moment the terms were written.
◆ If this is your question
Work on it out loud.
Free Mind Thursday is my weekly live call, and it costs nothing. Sign up at beyondunbound.com/freemind. Or get the next issue of The Signal free, below.