Barna Group's article, published October 9, 2024 as partner content in its State of the Church initiative with Gloo, reports a survey of 2,003 U.S. adults fielded online November 3 to 8, 2023, with a margin of error of plus or minus 2 points. It reports that 42% of all adults and 37% of Christians say they have deconstructed the faith of their youth, 36% of practicing and 37% of nonpracticing Christians among them. Those who left their faith moved toward atheism, agnosticism or no faith in similar shares, around two in five each. The page does not give exact question wording, define practicing, or give exact shares for the destinations, and the findings come from the organizations promoting the initiative.
PRRI's spotlight page, published July 21, 2025 from its 2023 Religious Change survey, describes exvangelicals as people who have left evangelicalism, whether for another Christian tradition, another religion or no religion, and reports they are 6% of Americans, 58% women, 58% in the South and 14% LGBTQ. Among unaffiliated white exvangelicals it lists reasons for leaving, including no longer believing the teachings (80%), negative teaching about or treatment of gay and lesbian people (58%), religion harming mental health (51%), a church too focused on politics (32%) and a family that was never very religious (30%). The page gives no sample sizes or field dates, covers only unaffiliated white exvangelicals for the reasons, and the reasons are self-reported and recalled.
Read together, Barna asks a broad self-label question and PRRI sizes a group defined by changed identity and asks why they left. The samples, definitions and wording differ, so the percentages cannot be compared. Neither measures what the process of deconstructing involved for the person.
◆ My Take
A self-label and a defined group
Barna's figure rests on one phrase, 'deconstructed the faith of their youth', and on people deciding for themselves whether it applied; it is reported for all adults (42%) and for Christians (37%). PRRI instead defines a group by a change in identity and reports why those people say they left.
Both pages are reports of what people said when asked. The reasons PRRI lists belong to one subgroup and came from recall.
◆ If this is your question
Work on it out loud.
Free Mind Thursday is my weekly live call, and it costs nothing. Sign up at beyondunbound.com/freemind. Or get the next issue of The Signal free, below.