Monthly letter · News · Topics · Identity · Dispatches · Est. 2026

Where the Real You Learns to Live, not Just Stand Up

TheSignal

Dispatch · Men

Men who step back from masculine expectations in a U.S. survey, and men told they scored as feminine in an experiment

A U.S. survey reports that men who sometimes act less manly to get ahead also reported more distress. A 2026 randomized experiment found no consistent political shift when men were told they scored as feminine. Each tests a large idea with a narrow measure.

James H. TippinsThe Autonomy Commission
DispatchMen
SourcesPsyPost on Sex Roles · PsyPost on the Journal of Experimental Political Science

On January 24, 2025, PsyPost (Mane Kara-Yakoubian) reported a Sex Roles study by Jessica Pfaffendorf and Terrence Hill, using the 2021 Crime, Health, and Politics Survey. It covers 803 men aged 18 to 91, described as nationally representative. The key measure was a single item asking whether the man sometimes acted less manly because it helped him get ahead. Younger men, men with college educations and men who had difficulty meeting basic needs were more likely to say yes. Saying yes was linked to lower reported mastery and to higher anger, anxiety, depression and psychological distress. The article notes that the single-item measure may limit reliability, and it does not state the design or give effect sizes.

On May 12, 2026, PsyPost (Eric W. Dolan) reported a Journal of Experimental Political Science replication of a 2013 study, by Claire Gothreau and Nicholas Haas. It used a randomized online survey of 2,774 U.S. adults, nationally representative, including 2,073 men. Participants completed a survey on masculine and feminine traits and then received feedback assigned at random; in the main condition, men were falsely told they fell in the feminine range. The article reports no consistent evidence that this changed men's political attitudes, including support for the Iraq War or views on gay rights. The authors say design differences from the original may explain the result and that the online format may have weakened the threat. The article adds that other researchers have reported links and describes the broader evidence as mixed. The article gives no effect sizes.

Read together, one source is a survey of what men report about their own behavior and distress, and the other is an experiment on how men react to a false score. They ask different questions in different years and do not confirm or contradict each other. Each reports averages across men, with a one-item measure in the first and a single round of feedback assigned at random in the second.

◆ My Take

Two short measures of a large idea

One source asks men a single question about acting less manly and links a yes to higher reported distress. The other tells men they scored as feminine and finds no consistent change in their politics. Both treat manliness as a standard against which men can be measured, one by asking and one by assigning a score.

Each source lists limits on how far its result reaches: the first relies on one survey item, and the second notes that an online format may have weakened the threat.

◆ If this is your question

Work on it out loud.

Free Mind Thursday is my weekly live call, and it costs nothing. Sign up at beyondunbound.com/freemind. Or get the next issue of The Signal free, below.