Monthly letter · News · Topics · Identity · Dispatches · Est. 2026

Where the Real You Learns to Live, not Just Stand Up

TheSignal

Dispatch · Women

Wanting children and not having them: a U.S. and Israel survey of 1,739 childless adults and a German study of 23,843 adults on family size

A PsyPost report on a survey of childless adults in the U.S. and Israel counts how many said they wanted children and felt unable to have them. A June 2026 PsyPost report on a German study links having more children than wanted to lower well-being, with childless groups not consistently lower. Both samples are adults, not women alone.

James H. TippinsThe Autonomy Commission
DispatchWomen
SourcesJournal of Marriage and Family, via PsyPost · Journal of Personality, via PsyPost

On October 18, 2024, PsyPost (Eric W. Dolan) reported a Journal of Marriage and Family study by Doyle P. Tate and Geva Shenkman, a cross-country online survey of 1,739 childless adults aged 18 to 54: 1,026 in the U.S. (422 of them sexual minorities, recruited through an online platform and paid) and 713 in Israel (326 sexual minorities, volunteers recruited online). Involuntary childlessness meant wanting children but feeling unable to become a parent. In the U.S., 52% of sexual minorities and 44% of heterosexuals reported it, and in Israel 68% and 32%. U.S. participants reported it more often and with more stress than Israeli participants, using a modified infertility-related stress scale. The article's lead gives 50% for U.S. participants overall, which does not match the 52% and 44% subgroup figures in its body. Limits include different sampling in each country, self-report and simple measures, and the article gives no p-values or effect sizes.

On June 3, 2026, PsyPost (Eric W. Dolan) reported a Journal of Personality study by Laura Buchinger and colleagues of 23,843 adults aged 18 to 100 in a German household survey. Each person gave an ideal number of children if there were no obstacles, which was compared with their number of biological children, producing five groups: fulfilled parents, unfulfilled parents, overfulfilled parents, involuntarily childless and childfree by choice. Overfulfilled parents, who had more children than they wanted, reported lower life satisfaction, family life satisfaction and emotional balance, with the article putting the gap at about a quarter of a standard deviation lower life satisfaction. The other groups were not consistently lower once income, employment and relationship status were accounted for. For adults past typical reproductive age, falling short of the desired number was linked to lower life satisfaction and emotional balance. The design is cross-sectional, covers Germany and biological children only, and the article gives no group sizes.

Read together, one source counts how many say they wanted children and have none and how stressful that is, and the other compares well-being by the gap between wanted and actual family size. The outcomes differ (an infertility-related stress scale and life satisfaction with emotional balance), as do the countries. The first article does not break the involuntary childlessness figures out by gender.

◆ My Take

One gap, measured two ways

In the first survey, involuntary childlessness is counted by asking about wanting children and feeling unable to become a parent, and stress is measured on an infertility-related scale. In the second, well-being is life satisfaction and emotional balance, and the involuntarily childless group did not score consistently lower once income, employment and relationship status were accounted for. These are different questions about a similar gap, and an answer to one is not an answer to the other.

The German study is cross-sectional, and neither article describes following people over time, so neither records how a person's feeling about the gap changed over the years.

◆ If this is your question

Work on it out loud.

Free Mind Thursday is my weekly live call, and it costs nothing. Sign up at beyondunbound.com/freemind. Or get the next issue of The Signal free, below.