Monthly letter · News · Topics · Identity · Dispatches · Est. 2026

Where the Real You Learns to Live, not Just Stand Up

TheSignal

Faith & Leaving

What happens to pastors who leave ministry? A 2024 study of 30 clergy who had left or were considering leaving finds many now call themselves spiritual but not religious

Open Theology (De Gruyter), vol. 10, article by Linda Mercadante, reported by the publisher's page · 2024 (received Apr 21, accepted May 13, 2024) · 30 former clergy, interviews

James H. Tippins

The pattern stands out. A group of clergy ended up, by the author's account, with beliefs that closely resemble those of the non-religious people she studied earlier. The study cannot say whether that is where they were heading all along or where leaving took them. It also cannot say what the role carried for them besides belief.

Why it matters to this work. The ten masks include Religion, where belonging can stand in for belief, and Roles, where a function can stand in for a person. This study asks what a group of clergy believe once they have left, or are weighing leaving, the function. The Masks

If you set down the role you hold most publicly, what would you still believe on the first morning?

Find the mask you wear most → A free reading on the ten Masks.

The story

Illustration

Linda Mercadante of the Methodist Theological School in Ohio interviewed thirty clergy who had left active ministry or were considering it about what they believe now. She reports that their changed beliefs closely resemble those of the non-religious people she described in her earlier book on the spiritual but not religious (SBNR). Of the thirty, 17 firmly identified as SBNR, 9 were sympathetic to the label without fully adopting it, 2 identified with Christian spirituality, and 2 said they were neither spiritual nor religious. She reports linking the shift to disillusionment with church life, including discrimination, bullying and institutional problems.

The author states that the study cannot claim to be representative. Recruitment was by snowball and convenience methods, starting with her former students and colleagues and adding volunteers from social media. Nearly half the interviewees were United Methodist and about 20% Presbyterian (PCUSA), so the findings lean toward Mainline denominations. Nearly half were Millennials, a little over a quarter Gen X and about a quarter Baby Boomers. Of those who had moved on, 6 moved into chaplaincy or counseling and 9 into non-profit work, and a few remain in ministry, mostly for economic reasons. This is a qualitative study of people's own accounts, so it cannot say how common this path is among all clergy who leave.

Read at Open Theology, Linda Mercadante, Clergy Becoming Spiritual but not Religious →

More from James