Anxiety and stress after a miscarriage: what a study of 650 women found at one and nine months
American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology, reported by ScienceDaily from an Imperial College London release · Jan 15, 2020 · over 650 women with early pregnancy loss, 171 comparison women
What this study makes visible is the calendar. The numbers are highest at one month and lower at nine, but at nine months nearly one in five women still screened positive for post-traumatic stress symptoms. The release does not describe the women's circumstances beyond the questionnaires, so the figures are only a record that the months after can be long.
Why it matters to this work. Invisible contracts include the unwritten terms of holding it together and not making a fuss. A loss that is early and often unseen by others is the kind of loss those terms can leave unspoken. Invisible Contracts
If a loss in your life went unmarked by other people, who knew about it, and who never did?
Where Are You Standing? → Six questions, two minutes, no email.The story
IllustrationResearchers from Imperial College London and KU Leuven followed women who had lost a pregnancy early, after a miscarriage before 12 weeks or an ectopic pregnancy, to see how they were doing afterward. The women were recruited at early pregnancy units in three London hospitals and filled in questionnaires one month, three months and nine months after the loss. The release reports that a comparison group of women with healthy pregnancies had significantly lower symptom levels. Post-traumatic stress symptoms were reported by 29% of the women at one month and 18% at nine months.
The other figures in the release: moderate to severe anxiety in 24% at one month and 17% at nine months, and moderate to severe depression in 11% and 6%. The sample was 537 early miscarriages and 116 ectopic pregnancies, plus 171 women in the comparison group, whose percentages the release does not give. The release says post-traumatic stress was measured with a screening questionnaire, not a clinical interview, so it does not amount to a diagnosis, and that women who were already struggling may have been more likely to take part, which could make the rates look higher than they are. This account rests on the press release, not the full paper.
More from James
- The 35 Chains: For the One Without the Child They Longed ForFrom the Commission. Thirty-five chains, and the thirty-five truths that dissolve them, written for this reader.
- The 35 Chains: For the One Who Lost the PregnancyFrom the Commission. Thirty-five chains, and the thirty-five truths that dissolve them, written for this reader.
- The 35 Chains: For the One at War With the MirrorFrom the Commission. Thirty-five chains, and the thirty-five truths that dissolve them, written for this reader.
- The 35 Chains: For Those Who Are Needed More Than They Are SeenFrom the Commission. Thirty-five chains, and the thirty-five truths that dissolve them, written for this reader.
- Women without children in later life: an Israeli interview study of 20 childless women over 60 on freedom, regret and fateThe paper reports that most participants held two explanations at once: their choices shaped their lives, and fate or a higher power did.
- Why fewer women want children: an Uppsala clinic survey series found 75% wanted children in 2023, down from 91% in 2014Two numbers carry the story: the share wanting children fell from 91% to 75% between 2014 and 2023, and the share unsure or not wanting them rose from about one in ten to about one in four.