Monthly letter · News · Topics · Identity · Dispatches · Est. 2026

Where the Real You Learns to Live, not Just Stand Up

TheSignal

Women

Infertility and identity: what women said about self-esteem and purpose in a 2021 interview study

BMJ Open · Nov 9, 2021 · 21 women who had struggled to conceive and 14 mental health professionals, Canada and the USA

James H. Tippins

One theme stands out: self-esteem, identity and purpose appear together in one category. The study cannot say how many women feel this, only that those who were interviewed described it. Because the themes were drawn from women and clinicians together, the picture is of distress that reaches past mood into who a woman understands herself to be.

Why it matters to this work. The masks include Roles, where a function stands in for the person. When the role a woman expected to fill is delayed or does not arrive, the study's third theme, a threat to identity and purpose, shows how much weight a role can carry. The Masks

Which role were you expecting to be in by now, and what did you assume it would say about you?

Find the mask you wear most → A free reading on the ten Masks.

The story

Illustration

Researchers at the University of Regina and colleagues interviewed 21 women aged 25 to 41 who had struggled to conceive for at least 12 months, along with 14 mental health professionals specialising in infertility, in Canada and the USA. Using thematic analysis, they described five themes: anxiety, mood disturbance, a threat to self-esteem, identity and purpose, the deterioration of the couple, and a weakened social support network. The aim was to identify what psychotherapy for infertility-related distress should target.

This is a qualitative study, so it describes themes and does not measure how common any of them are. The authors report that the sample was fairly uniform, all white and of high household income, with 76% of the women (16 of 21) reporting household income of C$113,000 or more, and that all participants were in heterosexual relationships, so the themes may differ for other groups. The introduction cites an estimated 30% to 40% of women at infertility tertiary care facilities with clinically significant depression and anxiety, a figure taken from earlier work, not found in this study.

Read at BMJ Open, Dube and colleagues, "Infertility-related distress and clinical targets for psychotherapy: a qualitative study" →

More from James